Employers are getting caught out. You know what I mean – they receive a resume from the perfect candidate… interview goes swimmingly and the references couldn’t be better! Then the employee starts and the threads start to unravel…
1/3 job applicants are guilty of telling lies in an interview (a recent survey by Galaxy Research of 1010 respondants shows). Whilst some of these are little white lies, there are a startling number of large whoppers being passed off as truths in applicants search for their dream job!
The most common lies were found to be:
- 17% stretching the truth with previous work experience
- 16% have friends acting as referees
- 10% overinflated previous salaries
- 6% fake references
- 3% bogus qualifications/education
So what can employers do to catch out the lies? Well the biggest issue (besides job applicants ‘faking’ their credentials) is that employers/managers don’t tend to follow a logical or documented process for recruiting. Most employers rely on a ‘gut feel’ of someone – and I mean no disrespect, but some of the most influential people in the world have been psychopaths (think Hitler, Manson etc…).
The LEAST predictive methods of candidate matching include 1) resumes, 2) unstructured interviews, and 3). unstructured reference checks. If you want to ensure that you are indeed gaining the best candidate for the role there are some easy steps you can take to reduce the risk of you getting taken for a ride!
Firstly, resumes are interesting little things – human nature means that we may subconsciously take the look and layout as more important than the content. No don’t get me wrong, the look, layout, spelling and grammar are all critically important, BUT so is the content. So my best suggestion is to have one of your trusted staff write a precis of each resume and staple it to the front BEFORE you go through the resumes. In this summary, you want the same information for ALL applicants – the information that is critical to the role and critical to your work environment (eg: previous experience, qualifications, work history, personal attributes…) BUT the idea is to make each summary comparable.
Secondly, you NEED a structure for your interview. To be able to fairly and accurately measure each applicant you need to ask the same series of questions, in the same order! Leave time at the end for the applicant to ask questions and then ensure you have a staff member note them for you and collate them at the end, so you can objectively see who asked intelligent and relevant questions.
Finally, have a set series of questions to ask referees. Ensure that you include some left of field questions to get a very accurate picture of the applicants relationship to the referee. I am a referee for a lot of my friends. But the interesting thing is these friends are people I have all managed in the past! You want to ask the referee how they know the applicant, what capacity did they work together, how long ago, what are the applicants good points, what are their bad points (this one is important as this will give you a genuine measure as to how realistic the reference really is – no one is perfect, but is your applicant capable of taking responsibility and fixing their errors? or do they blame others and hide?). Asking some of the negatives will actually help you determine what your potential applicant will perform like under pressure AND it will also send up red flags if the referee can’t answer the tough questions! Again, once the reference checks have been done, get someone independent to type summaries out that you can compare apples with apples.
In the end – you can never be 100% sure what someone will be like until they start working for you, but add these measurable criteria and ensure that the choice is more than just gut feel, or you may end up with a Ted Bundy!
PS: of course if you use Wise Recruitment, we do all of these processes on your behalf, PLUS we use Evidence Based Testing for qualifications and experience. This totally removes the guess work and then you can pick the best applicant on your gut feel, because we have weeded out the lies!